MATTHIJS NAIVEU
Leiden 1647 - 1726 Amsterdam
Grapes in a Niche
Canvas, 57 x 46.5 cm
Signed : Naiveu (left on plinth)
Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, The Hague

Naiveu has done his best to trick the observer, and the niche
forms an essential element in this. Viewed at eye level the
trompe-l'oeil effect is remarkable. The niche appears to be part of
the wall on which the painting is hung, making the bunch of grapes
look as though it is attached to the wall instead of being part of
the picture. Attracted by the fruit, some insects have landed on
the grapes, others on the marble. Have they been fooled by the
artist, just as the birds were by Parrhasios? No, it is more
subtle. They, too, are painted and in turn fool the human observer.
In that sense Naiveu is at once Zeuxis and Parrhasios.
In painterly terms this picture is extremely accomplished. The
heavy bunch of grapes and the venous leaves have been exquisitely
rendered; while the handling of light and the curling leaves deftly
create an illusion of three-dimensionality, emphasised by the fact
that some of the leaves extend round the side of the niche. In
addition to the trompe l'oeil effect, the picture is also
interesting for its symbolism. Here the grapes may symbolise the
life and death of Christ, while the pomegranate alludes to his
resurrection.